- Cinematic Fanatic
- Posts
- The Pitt vs ER Lawsuit
The Pitt vs ER Lawsuit
Plus: David Fincher's fav films, sitcom rag dolls, and Jon Lovitz to revive The Critic?
👋 Your watchlist just got better. From overlooked gems to major releases, we keep cinematic tastemakers up-to-date on what’s happening, like what to watch this week:
🎥 The Grove | 4.4
🎥 Freaky Tales | 4.4
📺 Black Mirror S7 | 4.10
Read time: 3 minutes | 639 words
TRENDING
🎬 YES! Coyote vs. Acme escapes Warner Bros. shelving – Ketchup Entertainment pays rumored $50M for worldwide rights to Looney Tunes film.
✍ David Fincher's handwritten list of favorite films includes Taxi Driver, Alien, Paper Moon, and The Exorcist (see more).
The Order is the hidden gem film of 2024 (if you’ve seen the film, check out this video on hunter vs the hunted).
📢 Jon Lovitz rallies The Critic revival – creator Al Jean joins campaign as fans mobilize to convince studio through massive social support.
🎸 First look at The Beatles cast together, includes Paul Mescal (Gladiator II) as Paul McCartney and Barry Keoghan (The Batman) as Ringo Starr.
🚫 YouTube cracks down on AI trailer scammers – fake movie preview channels lose monetization in platform-wide purge.
🎭 HIM poster debuts – Marlon Wayans, Tyriq Withers tackle Jordan Peele-produced sports horror with spaghetti Western flair.
🧸 Should we bring back rag dolls that don't look remotely like people? Here's one for Will Smith as The Fresh Prince as a reminder.
TOGETHER WITH BROOKS ELMS
Feeling stuck in your screenwriting journey?

According to Brooks Elms, Hollywood Screenwriter / Life Coach for Writers, success in Hollywood has two main obstacles:
How do you write/direct at the pro level? (SHOW)
How do you get your material into the right hands? (BUSINESS)
Brooks will walk you through his simple framework for each obstacle in a free Group Coaching Call.
Hollywood is hyper-competitive and there's no magic wand. But Brooks' frameworks will give you a fighting chance, and they're battle tested - he's in WGA where he’s written 45 screenplays, directed 2 indie features, and coached 100+ writers to apply the framework to their own unique situations, so this can help you too!
Are you interested in joining this free group call? |
FEATURE
⚖️ Is The Pitt Just ER 2.0? Lawsuit, Explained
Max's New Medical Drama Embroiled in High-Stakes Ownership Dispute…
The critically acclaimed series "The Pitt" has become the center of a contentious legal battle as Michael Crichton's estate claims the new medical drama is nothing more than an unauthorized spin-off of the iconic NBC series "ER" – potentially violating agreements that Crichton himself established decades ago regarding derivative works.
"The Pitt is ER. It's not like ER, it's not kind of ER, it's not sort of ER," asserts the lawsuit filed by Sherri Crichton, widow of the late "Jurassic Park" author. The premise directly challenges the creative independence claimed by "The Pitt" team, suggesting a calculated maneuver to rebrand "ER" while avoiding proper attribution and compensation.
This woman is the glue that holds the pitt together
— fetid moppet (@flawedcrystals)
2:30 AM • Mar 31, 2025
The lawsuit highlights several factors that allegedly connect the two medical dramas:
"Simply moved the show from Chicago to Pittsburgh, rebranded it 'The Pitt,' and has plowed ahead without any attribution or compensation for Crichton and his heirs."
The evidence presented becomes more compelling when examining the overlapping personnel between both productions. "Noah Wyle (who played Dr. John Carter on the NBC show for 11 seasons), 'ER' producer John Wells, and creator R. Scott Gemmill are all major components of 'The Pitt' – a connection that the Crichton estate argues cannot be coincidental and represents 'a personal betrayal of a 30-year friendship.'"
What makes this case particularly significant is that Warner Bros. has firmly rejected these characterizations. "While they are both medical dramas set in hospitals, this does not make 'The Pitt' a 'derivative work'... Plaintiff does not own this generic concept, shared by numerous medical dramas set in hospitals that have aired before, during, and after 'ER.'"
As "The Pitt" moves forward with its recently announced second season, what began as creative excitement has evolved into one of entertainment's most fascinating legal disputes about creator rights, intellectual property, and the fine line between inspiration and derivation.
THE PITT has been firing on all cylinders these few weeks; and it shows what you can do with the fullest tools of filmmaking: complex layers of movement, paced cutting, and overlapping dialogue. It’s also closer to the lived experience of an event than all this one-shot nonsense.
— Robert King (@RKing618)
2:50 PM • Mar 29, 2025
TOGETHER WITH RUNDOWN AI
Learn AI in 5 minutes a day
This is the easiest way for a busy person wanting to learn AI in as little time as possible:
Sign up for The Rundown AI newsletter
They send you 5-minute email updates on the latest AI news and how to use it
You learn how to become 2x more productive by leveraging AI
PUNCHLINES
i need a Fathom Events where they run all 15 episodes of The Pitt in one long go so that i can experience the entire 15-hour shift properly
— claira curtis (@clairacurtis)
10:35 PM • Mar 29, 2025
Hey Jessica, fun fact, you don't actually love movies
— TheRealMattC (@TheRealMattC)
7:52 PM • Mar 27, 2025